A Deserted Long Island Farmhouse Stayed Unnoticed for Four Decades!


Although there are nearly eight million homeowners in the heavily urbanized state of New York, some are much more interesting than others. Each construction has a tale, some of which tell conflicting narratives every day.

Others have occurrences that are buried deep down for years, merely desperately looking to be accessed. This particular property did wait for somebody to unearth the secret behind the walls for forty years.

Neighbors Were Clueless About The Gem In Their Midst

Bryan Sansivero, a distinguished photo-artist, got the information about this mysterious property and asked the city authorities to explore it. The journey takes you to another timespan.

Bryan Sansivero was astonished at how the farmhouse with a long driveway that extends to the rear was so neatly hidden. This is what you’d call hiding in clear view since it was smack in the middle of a bustling community. However, the owners wanted privacy, so this single-room country house went undetected. He says the experience felt like time had stopped.


The Facade Was Breathtaking At One Point

The Victorian residence was once made impressive by its appeal but now it decays from neglect. Here we can see the primary structure that had been constructed in the mid-1800s. The roof had sagged, with a central column having fallen.

There are nine acres, with a wide range of amenities to suit every need the family had. An area to smoke meat, a garage, milking section, barn for the sheep, stable for their horses, and a few extra barns. Sansivero hopes that his photos will help in some way to rehabilitate a magnificent and historically meaningful residence.


This Once Lovely Home Was Constructed Prior To The Civil War

You’ll have to head to Commack Village, which was once Native American territory, to find the historic farmhouse. It’s in the Suffolk County area of New York.

Urbanization has brought higher levels of development to the location of the Carll Ranch. The ranch has been in existence since the beginning of the 18th century, ahead of the Civil War. So, let us see what awaits us inside…


It May Be Neglected, But Loads Of Treasure Lay Inside

Sansivero repeatedly took photos of the plantation with the permission of the area school officials and the committee. He said that every time he visited, he came up with more items that needed to be highlighted.

There have been a vast number of precious articles of the past. These scarce photographs remind how unique the property was before it was abandoned and eventually demolished.


Marion Carll Led a Busy Lifestyle

Marion Carll was a community stalwart and much respected. She was a school trustee and helped to find the first PTA.

Education was an integral part of Carll’s life, so it was no surprise that she had chosen the Board for the Commack School Board and the District for academic and chronological purposes. This stylish pair of footwear seen in the image above were likely Ms. Carll’s own.


She Was Attempting To Preserve The Antique Aesthetic

As a lover of artifacts, Marion Carll aimed to retain the farmhouse’s personality that had been designed in the 18th century as much as possible. She didn’t try to modernize the residence in any way.

Due to her desire to maintain history, there are a lot of old vintage collectibles on the site. Despite being abandoned so many years back, it seemed that Marion Carll was dwelling in a completely different era.


Connections To Walt Whitman We're Found At The Home

The photos show the existence of the Carll family. A local history book focusing on past things (similar to the house decor) disclosed a few fascinating family property facts.

“The property where the farm lies, away from Commack Road, had been occupied by the Secatougue Indian tribe. This information was obtained from 17th-century records showing the lineage connection to Walt Whitman.” Indians originally owned it before being transferred to Whitman’s ancestors.


A Perilous Stairwell Awaits

You can see a large staircase in front of the house. There’s another home stairway to the cellar. The stairs on the next flight were not in decent condition.

The photographer notes that they only saw the basement one time, and they didn’t get any photos, unfortunately. The stairs broke as they walked back out of the basement, so trying to get more photos would have proven dangerous.


The Parlor With Its Grand Piano Was Beyond Amazing

Even with all the dirt and residue being built up, this room is a replica of when Ms. Carll was living there. This finely carved piano has been playing some lovely music for a few years.

Piano and other instruments were the primary means of entertainment prior to the development of the radio. Households would gather to have karaoke or listen to their favorite tunes.


A Display Of Historical Items

Pots, pans, and glass bottles are scattered around the room. Collectors are now snapping antique bottles like those, with a desire to attain a great article of the past—some of the packages included standard household products such as olive oil and even milk of magnesia.

There is even a small brochure advertising the 33rd staging of the Sea Girt tournament, which involves multiple states. The American International Riflers Association organized the event in the 19th century.


Even The Clock Was Stuck In Time

This alarm clock had its hands frozen at 02:54, but we’ll never know the exact date or if it was morning or night when the clock stopped ticking. Next is a bottle that is used to store ammonia, which is a prominent household cleaning agent.

Antique fortune hunters who seek to explore the property will not get a chance to do so. Following the work of Sansivero, the building was cleared up. All valuable items have been placed in safekeeping while the property has round-the-clock security.


Even The Attic Room Storage Has Stories

The farmhouse not only has a cellar but also an attic storage area. Here, too, beds imply that the room may have been utilized for sleeping—probably for staff members.

The walls are lined with many metal crinoline frocks dangling from wall brackets. The undergrowth gained popularity across several continents after getting its patent in the mid-19th century. They seem to maintain their excellent condition despite their age.


The Live Still-Art Remained Unscathed For Years

These artificial flowers have withstood the test of time, having been abandoned for decades. Surprisingly, their colors are still bright and rich. A teacup sits adjacent to some flowers, awaiting the arrival of the owner to take a sip.

The cloth on the furniture here did not stand well; however, you can tell it looked nice when it was new. Settings of this caliber are what compelled the photographer to state that the house felt so much like going back to the Victorian era compared to any other home he’d ever ventured into.


Of Course, An Educator Needs A Desk

Caroll was probably working at this desk. She was enrolled in a single-room schoolhouse while growing up in the farmhouse. Carll went to high school in the Queens area of New York and then returned to her hometown as an educator.

She encouraged schoolmates to tour the farm to gain better knowledge about life on a farm, leading to a local school named Marion E. Carll in 1957. We know that Carll donated the property to the school community.


The Property Had A Line Of Outbuildings

The vast acreage farmhouse has multiple structures, including barns and carports, a smokehouse, and various barns.

This image shows the inside of the barn. Ancient farm tools in the facility assisted with highlighting the history of the property as a functional plantation. Caroll asked that the buildings be kept as monuments.


What Secrets Lay Inside The Safety Box?

The way the lock system is built on this safe has sparked a lot of people’s interest in what it holds. It was created by a safe entity located in Cincinnati.

A name is engraved on the safe, which the research shows as a former member of staff at the Dental Department of the University of Buffalo. It has not been ascertained how secure the farm has gotten.


Fireplaces In Every Section Of The House

Fireplaces were typical in older homes before central air systems began to be installed within houses. The residence of Carll had several fireplaces. Some of them still look fantastic, including this one made of marble.

This would be very welcome to anyone sitting in the corner reading or talking, especially on a frigid night. Except for the peeling wallpapers, the room is perhaps a good picture of how it was when Carll was living there.


One Particular Fireplace Stood Out

This lovely setup features a well-attired female portrait, sitting nicely atop the mantle of the fireplace, which remains unscathed despite its age. Another picture has two young children, while a third has only one kid and a dog.

Sitting on the beautiful mantle as well is a teacup, as though someone rests it there and forgets to pick it up. It’s clear that Ms. Carll had electricity, which could be deemed a touch of modernization, as there were two lamps, one of which is still intact and the other badly torn.


Heritage Was Strewn Across Every Nook and Cranny

Sansivero said the house has a lot of history lying around. Every room brandished something new to observe, like this blue and-white china set in perfect order.

There are numerous additional artifacts in this scene, such as an oil lamp and a teapot. The roof in this compartment has deteriorated and now looks set to fall apart.


Parts Of The Farmhouse Have Been Reasonably Preserved, Unlike Others

The renowned photographer says they visited the bedroom, then decided to venture upstairs to the building. The top floor was used as a storehouse and what seemed to be lodging for the household staff.

The entire ceiling had collapsed, and the walls had been painted in multiple areas. In the meantime, the trash lined up the ground in that section of the house. The hallway had many reminders of history and evidence of past lifestyle occupants.


Necessary To Register It As A Historical Place

Although the estate is falling apart, over a million other properties, have been placed in the National Registry. This quaint farmhouse might be a perfect addition to that list.

There are a few criteria to be included in the register. Properties must comply with one, including having made a significant contribution to American history, being linked to a remarkable individual, having unique architectural aspects, or being critical to history.


Learning About The History of the Carlls

This image below illustrates Carll in the mid-1900s. The photo’s website says that Carll’s sister and two brothers were police officers, and her daughter owned a men’s shoe factory.

The Carll family has a prosperous history on Long Island, including ties to the Sagitikos Manor, which was transferred to the Setauket Thompson family, then to the Gardiner family. Simultaneously, the Carlls continued to be distinguished members of neighborhoods in and around the Huntington area.


These Photos Offer Even More Details on the Carll's Lives

This batch of photographs depicting the Carlls offers greater insight into the famous family and how they lived their lives. The clothes that they wore spoke volumes about their societal status.

Rummaging through many of the pictures and paperwork strewed across the house sheds more light on the family’s history and the type of lifestyle they led, Sansivero said. These valuable heirlooms have been spread for temporary display but have since been taken off the property for safekeeping.


Mirror, Mirror on the Wall, What's Going on Inside These Halls?

Years ahead of watching popular TV programs for inspiration on how to decorate one’s homes, shiplap was the choice for making your walls look layered and attractive. Many households, including the Carll farm, were drawn to this popular design.

Well-designed mirrors such as the one seen here would help to accentuate the wall, adding great character to the washroom or hallway where they were mainly placed. These designs will last the test of time and are still sought after today.


The Charm of That Era Shone Brightly!

According to the not-for-profit entity striving to restore the property to its former glory while preserving it, they appreciate the farm they received and want to honor the wishes of the late owner. Electricity will be the only contemporary amenity, heating, and a couple of restrooms.

What you are looking at is an ancient water storage container known as an ewer (or pitcher) sitting on the nicely-designed dresser. In the event no water was available, they would be the backup for potable water indoors. Mrs. Carll’s home is truly a glimpse into the past.


Wagons and Sleighs Show How Far Back This House Dates

The first thing on most people’s minds upon seeing the sleigh involves Santa Claus. And rightfully so since Ms. Carll was such a giving person. Horses hauled both the sleigh and car. The plow beside them is evidence of the work that went on at the farm.

The items in this barn are as entrenched in history as those found in the interior. Every angle of the house is a history lesson, which explains why Ms. Carll wanted it to be preserved.


Mrs. Carll Appeared To Make Her Own Clothes

Here’s Mrs. Carl’s sewing device, precisely where she used it, probably for many years. You can see wool sitting beside the machine, and it would not be far-fetched to think that it came from the many sheep they raised on the property as well.

A lot of the clothing items found inside the house were not your typical store-bought items, and were designed nicely. It gives the impression that she was a stylist as much as she was an educator. The electric lamp beside her sewing machine suggests that she sewed often during the nighttime.


Great Embroidery Work Was On Display

A mannequin blouse and a threaded spool container were seen in the main bedroom of the house. Ms. Carll seems to have been a great stitcher.

Despite being exposed for so many years, the blouse exhibited a great deal of detail and elaborate embroidery work. Ms. Carll may have designed it.


This Cabinet Was The Ventral Spot For Emergency Needs

Here’s a larger shot of the clock and the bottle scene we’ve seen earlier. This curio cabinet is covered by a variety of interesting antiques. There’s a ceramic horse and a rabbit here, and a lot of bottles of medicine.

Unfortunately, most of their labels are too disintegrated to read. The bottom shelf contains some maps and wooden crates, including one labeled “Kirkman’s.” The smaller bottles seen in these crates may have held spices such as salt and pepper.


Medicine For A Myriad of Illnesses

Not only was Ms. Carll into farming, teaching, and sewing, she was serious about staying healthy, as this collection of medicine bottles suggests. From indigestion issues to skin problems, she had something to address them all.

Even the Milk of Magnesia which is still very popular today, was there in large size. She clearly wasn’t taking any chances and wanted to make sure there’s a treatment for anything that could arise, just in case it did.


Leisure And Scholarly Books Were In Abundance

It’s natural for an educator and historian like Marion Carll to be an avid reader. There are several bookcases all over the house. This case is made up of crates that once held “Splendor Sunkist Oranges” from the San Fernando Heights Orange Association in San Fernando, California.

We see a well-used dictionary, a government book, one called “Modern Europeans,” and many more. Most of them seem to be in reasonably good shape in terms of their surroundings.


Status of Endangered

For the past decade, historians led by Robert Hughes have made a sustained effort to ensure that the property is preserved. They did not stop until it was placed on the list for endangered properties. Rightfully so, because if this property is not considered being historic, then what is?

Mr. Hughes and others raise funds to ensure that the property does not fall back into a state of neglect. He says this time machine should be viewed for what it is and treated accordingly.


Preserving This Previous Part Of History

The council of the Commack School District and the locals have been working to examine the appropriate use of the remarkable family farm, which is part of the town park.

The team working to protect the family farm says they are working to make it a restored historic site, and recommendations include a functioning organic farm and a teaching center. Ms. Carll would undoubtedly have loved that idea.