Repair or replace

Repair or Replace Your AC or Furnace? How to Decide

By Sam Delaney · 2 min read
Updated November 16, 2026
Compare quotes from local HVAC contractors

Enter your ZIP code to see which HVAC contractors near you can quote a repair or replacement.

Free to use. If you request quotes, your details go to a matching partner and local pros may contact you. Home Knowledge may earn a fee.

HVAC systems tend to fail on the hottest or coldest day of the year, when everyone else's is failing too. That is the worst time to make a five-figure decision, so it helps to know the rules of thumb in advance.

Start with the age

InterNACHI, the home inspectors' association, gives these typical life spans:

Equipment Typical life span
Central air conditioner 7 to 15 years
Heat pump 10 to 15 years
Gas furnace 15 to 25 years
Boiler Around 40 years
Ductwork 60 to 100 years
Compare quotes from local HVAC contractors

Enter your ZIP code to see which HVAC contractors near you can quote a repair or replacement.

Free to use. If you request quotes, your details go to a matching partner and local pros may contact you. Home Knowledge may earn a fee.

The model and serial numbers on the unit's label usually show the manufacture date; a quick search for the brand's serial number format will tell you how to read it.

Signs a repair is enough

  • A young system with one failed part: a capacitor, contactor, igniter, flame sensor or fan motor.
  • A clogged condensate line or a dirty filter causing the problem.
  • A thermostat or wiring fault.
  • The system worked well until this one failure.

Signs replacement makes sense

  • The system is near or past the age ranges above and needs a major part, like a compressor, heat exchanger or coil.
  • Repairs are becoming yearly events.
  • Uneven temperatures, rising energy bills or a system that runs constantly.
  • A cracked furnace heat exchanger. This can leak carbon monoxide; treat it as a safety issue and do not keep running the furnace.
  • An older AC that uses R-22 refrigerant, which is no longer produced in the United States, making leak repairs very expensive.

A simple way to weigh it

A common rule among contractors is to multiply the system's age by the repair cost. If the number is above about $5,000, replacement usually makes more sense. It is a rough guide, not a law, but it is a sensible check. For example, a 12-year-old AC with a $600 repair comes to $7,200, so start getting replacement quotes.

If you replace one half, check the other

Air conditioners and furnaces work as a matched pair, sharing the indoor coil and blower. Replacing a 14-year-old AC while keeping a 14-year-old furnace can mean paying for a second visit in two years. Ask about replacing both, or switching to a heat pump. Our comparison guide explains the options.

Compare quotes from local HVAC contractors

Enter your ZIP code to see which HVAC contractors near you can quote a repair or replacement.

Free to use. If you request quotes, your details go to a matching partner and local pros may contact you. Home Knowledge may earn a fee.