Asphalt Shingles vs Metal Roofing: Cost, Lifespan and Which to Choose
Enter your ZIP code to see which roofers near you can quote your repair or replacement.
Free to use. If you request quotes, your details go to a matching partner and local pros may contact you. Home Knowledge may earn a fee.Most re-roofing decisions in the United States come down to two choices: asphalt shingles, which cover the large majority of American homes, or metal, which costs more up front and lasts a lot longer. Tile and slate are wonderful roofs on the houses built for them, but they are heavy and expensive, and few homeowners switch to them.
So the real question is usually this one: is metal worth paying roughly twice as much?
Side by side
| Architectural asphalt shingles | Metal roofing | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical installed cost per sq ft | $4.50 to $8 | $8 to $14 |
| Expected lifespan | About 30 years (InterNACHI) | 40 to 70 years |
| Share of cost recouped at resale (2025) | About 67.5% | About 50% |
| Repairs | Easy and cheap; any roofer can do it | Specialist work; panels are harder to patch |
| Weight | Moderate | Light |
| Look | Fits almost any neighborhood | Modern or farmhouse; also made to look like shingles |
Enter your ZIP code to see which roofers near you can quote your repair or replacement.
Free to use. If you request quotes, your details go to a matching partner and local pros may contact you. Home Knowledge may earn a fee.Costs are 2026 ranges from published cost guides and vary a lot by region. Resale figures come from the 2025 Cost vs Value report.
Price today vs price per year
Asphalt wins on the first check you write, usually by thousands of dollars. Metal starts to look better when you divide the price by the years it lasts. If an architectural shingle roof lasts 25 to 30 years and a metal roof lasts 50 or more, the metal roof can cost less per year of service, even at twice the price.
That math only works if you stay in the house. The Cost vs Value report found buyers pay back a smaller share of a metal roof's cost at resale than of an asphalt roof's. If you expect to move within ten years, the extra spend on metal mostly benefits the next owner.
Weather, climate and fire
Metal sheds snow well, holds up to high winds when properly fastened and does not burn, which matters in wildfire country. Light-colored or coated metal roofs also reflect more summer heat than dark shingles.
Asphalt shingles handle most climates fine, but heat and strong sun age them faster, and hail can bruise them. Metal can dent in a bad hailstorm too; the dents are usually cosmetic, but check how your insurer treats them, since some policies exclude cosmetic damage to metal roofs.
Noise and other worries
The rain-on-a-tin-roof myth is mostly about barns. On a house, metal goes over solid decking and underlayment, with an attic and insulation below, and most people do not notice a difference indoors. Lightning is not more likely to strike a metal roof either.
Metal's real drawbacks are practical. Fewer contractors install it well, repairs need someone who knows the panel system and a poorly installed metal roof can leak at the fasteners. Ask any metal installer how many metal roofs they have done and get references for jobs that are several years old.
Which one we would choose
Asphalt makes sense if you are budget-limited, plan to move within about ten years or want the widest choice of contractors. Metal makes sense if this is your long-term home, you live with heavy snow, high wind or wildfire risk, or you simply never want to re-roof again.
Either way, the installer matters as much as the material. A great shingle roof beats a badly installed metal one. Our guide to hiring a roofer covers what to check.
Enter your ZIP code to see which roofers near you can quote your repair or replacement.
Free to use. If you request quotes, your details go to a matching partner and local pros may contact you. Home Knowledge may earn a fee.