Hiring a pro

How to Hire a Roofer: Checks, Questions and Red Flags

By Sam Delaney · 3 min read
Updated November 16, 2026
Compare quotes from local roofers

Enter your ZIP code to see which roofers near you can quote your repair or replacement.

Free to use. If you request quotes, your details go to a matching partner and local pros may contact you. Home Knowledge may earn a fee.

The roofing material matters less than the people nailing it down. A careful crew will get decades out of an ordinary shingle; a sloppy one can make an expensive roof leak in its first winter. Hiring well takes an afternoon of checking, and it is the most valuable afternoon in the whole project.

Find three local roofers

Start with recommendations from neighbors who had work done in the last few years, then add companies you find yourself. Get at least three written estimates. The Better Business Bureau, insurers like State Farm and the FTC all give the same advice: compare several established, local contractors, and do not let anyone rush you.

Local matters. A roofer with an office in your area will still be around when you need the warranty honored.

Check credentials before anyone climbs up

  • License. Licensing rules for roofers vary by state, and some states have none. Check your state or county contractor licensing board online. The FTC recommends confirming the license with the state or county yourself.
  • Insurance. Ask for certificates of general liability and workers' compensation insurance, and call the insurer to confirm they are current. Without workers' comp, an injury on your roof can become your problem.
  • Reputation. Search the company's name with words like "complaint" and "scam," as the FTC suggests. Check BBB records and reviews, and be suspicious of a burst of five-star reviews posted in a short time.
  • References. Ask for two or three customers from jobs done at least a couple of years ago, so you hear how the roof has held up.

What a good written estimate includes

A one-line quote is not an estimate. A useful one spells out:

Item What to look for
Roof size Number of squares measured
Materials Brand and product line of shingles, underlayment, flashing and vents
Tear-off Number of layers removed and disposal included
Decking Price per sheet for any rotten wood they replace
Permits Who pulls the permit, and whether the fee is included
Schedule and cleanup Start date, duration, magnetic sweep for nails
Warranties Manufacturer warranty plus the roofer's own workmanship warranty, in years
Payment schedule Deposit amount and when the balance is due
Compare quotes from local roofers

Enter your ZIP code to see which roofers near you can quote your repair or replacement.

Free to use. If you request quotes, your details go to a matching partner and local pros may contact you. Home Knowledge may earn a fee.

If one quote is far below the others, line it up against this list. It usually leaves something out.

Red flags

  • A contractor who knocks on your door right after a storm offering a free inspection. The BBB and the FTC both warn about these storm chasers.
  • Pressure to sign today, or a "special price" that expires tonight.
  • A demand for full payment up front, or payment in cash, gift cards, wire transfers, payment apps or crypto. The FTC lists all of these as warning signs.
  • No physical address, only a phone number or P.O. box.
  • An offer to "cover your deductible." Waiving an insurance deductible is illegal in some states and is a classic sign of insurance fraud.
  • No written contract.

Sign the contract, then pay on schedule

Get every promise in writing, including the materials, cleanup and warranty terms from the estimate. Pay a reasonable deposit and the balance when the work is finished and the permit is closed out. The FTC suggests paying by credit card where you can, which gives you some protection if something goes wrong.

If you sign a contract at your home with a salesperson who came to you, the FTC's Cooling-Off Rule generally gives you three business days to cancel. Ask the contractor for the cancellation form.

After the job

Walk the property with the crew lead, look for nails in the lawn and driveway, and ask for the manufacturer warranty registration and the final permit sign-off. Keep the contract, invoice and photos together. You will want them for insurance, and when you sell.

Compare quotes from local roofers

Enter your ZIP code to see which roofers near you can quote your repair or replacement.

Free to use. If you request quotes, your details go to a matching partner and local pros may contact you. Home Knowledge may earn a fee.